fragsta,
I agree that the Addon Depot doesn't have a full list of addons.
But what I said was:
Why create a List and a Depot, when the Depot can serve as the List? Why create, maintain and staff a list that can be better served by somewhere like the Addon Depot?
And OFPEC's policy on Addons is simply that they comply with the TAG system (which, btw, is also a BIS requirement), and that they work.
We accept all addons as long as they meet TAG and 'it works' requirements.ie: Check out LegaWarz as an example.
And I know that 99% of addon makers voluntarily adhere to the TAG standard anyway, so its not as much an issue as you think.
As for the untagged, messed up addons ... I'm not sure what your point is.
Surely they're not worth listing/hosting if they're not functional? If you do, you'll find people will start avoiding the List, as you're 'supplying' them with broken addons.
And if they work but aren't tagged, we have instructions guiding them how to TAG their addon. Its easily done.
So considering all the above, wouldn't you agree that using a storage Depot as the List would better serve the community?