Hey Tom (heh, feel like I'm talking to myself here), I decided to try your mission. You should feel very honored. I only have time to beta test one mission, and I chose yours
Anyway, here is my review.
Overview/Readme
Good
Intro:
For a non-scripted intro, this is pretty good. You must have spent quite a lot of time getting it right. The only complaint is that it took a loooooooooooong time for the Shilka to get destroyed.
Briefing:
Looks good, tells me everything I need to know. One spelling mistake in the intel section of the notes, though. Wether should be Whether.
Mission:
Ok, so I hop in the HMMVENSLFLDFJLKAS, or whatever the accronym is for the hummer, and head off to base. Everything looks good, stuff is going on, the base seems reasonably alive. I hop into my beloved A10 and taxi for departure. At this point I get a hint that the convoy is leaving. Oops, I must be playing in Cadet mode
How embarrassing. Anyway. I advance the throttle and those marvelous engines come to life and begin to accelerate the aircraft down the runway. Faster and faster unti......sorry. I took off, headed south, and met the convoy. After a few strafing runs with the cannon and putting a maverick up a Shilkas a**, I complete the objective and begin to head home. As I near the base I get the radio message about the enemy plane. One suggestion here, include the direction the plane is coming from, in this case, north. About this time I get another hint that the convoy is almost at the destination. Wait a minute...I killed them all. Fix it so that if the convoy is dead there is no hint. Moving on...we have a dogfight, and me being the superior pilot I naturally win (thank you, thank you, I'll sign autographs later). I then make a flawless landing and taxi to the ramp. Btw, I love the repair truck and ambulance coming up to the aircraft, it makes the base feel so...alive. One bug with this, though. The repair truck kept coming and bumping into the A10.
Mission complete (who would have doubted)
Debrief:
Good enough, it works for me.
My kills:
Su25
Shilka
Ural
Soldier
Pilot
3 Crew
UAZ
Outro:
None
Summary:
For being your first public beta this mission is quite nice, I congratulate you. I liked the fact it was short...it allowed a college student like me to play OFP again, if only for a short moment. You also covered most aspects of flying in this mission, and I didn't feel bored at any time during the mission. The only thing I could suggest to make it slightly harder is to have 2 Su25s instead of 1. Here are the things I thought needed work:
A10 takes forever to kill Shilka in intro
Spelling error: Wether - Whether
Include direction of Su25 in radio message
Remove hint of convoy approaching destination of convoy is dead
Stop the repair truck from bumping into my A10...damn driver must be from Michigan (for those of you who are not from the states, people from Michigan can't drive for sh*t)
That's about all. You have a nice, short mission here. I like it, it will stay on my HD.
-Pilot